Who is a Chef? Who is a Cook?

There’s a lot of confusion out there about just what constitutes a “chef” versus a “cook.” Oh yes, and it’s a question that many writers have tried to answer. Nothing new there. I’m a big believer in defining terms, realizing of course that terminology and words change meanings over the years.

But, that said, and in the wake of recent comments made by a current food star and self-described chef, who states that a certain well-respected chef was actually not a chef, I decided to dig a little deeper into the murky pool of definitions and dogma and see what burbled up.

The most basic explanation of the term “chef” is this: chef de cuisine, which basically translates to “leader,” “boss,” and/or “chief.” Obviously, the phrase comes from the French and signifies a person who is in charge of every aspect of the kitchen, from ordering food to creating menus to supervising the staff, usually in a restaurant, although some would toss caterers into the mix. However, the key, I believe, lies in the word “restaurant.” A chef works in a restaurant, with day-to-day pressure.

Another aspect of chefdom lies in the training, including intense instruction in sanitation, accounting, and purchasing. Traditionally, a chef – usually male – entered the kitchen at a very young age and started from the bottom, which meant no glory and a lot of pot scrubbing and dull cutting chores involving tiny cubes of vegetables (mirepoix).

I might argue that cooks do much the same work. True. But it’s on a smaller scale, without the day-to-day pressure. There’s nothing wrong with being a cook, except that being a mere cook seems to be permeated with the aura of “servant.”

Some cooks take on the moniker “chef” to add allure and credibility to their persona.

In spite of the title of her TV show, “The French Chef,” Julia Child never considered herself a chef. Nigella Lawson doesn’t call herself a chef. There’s nothing wrong with being a cook, nothing at all. I’m one myself, even though I have worked in restaurants and helped manage one in West Africa.

And just in case my comments rankle, here’s a good summary of the issue by one chef – the real deal – who comes down hard on those who call themselves chefs without the blood, sweat, and tears behind the title:

“No other profession permits this sort of fraudulence. Imagine going to the hospital and finding out the doctor about to operate on you never actually went to school, and has no professional medical training, but is a huge fan of medicine and has read medical journals, watched all the medical shows on television, owns his own set of surgery tools, and worked a couple of summers as a hospital intern.”

So what do you think? When is a cook, well, a chef?

And who’s really the chef in this case?

© 2015 C. Bertelsen

Advertisements

5 Comments Add yours

  1. Tony Flanagan says:

    I think of a Chef as the person who puts the menu together, and the Cook as the person who executes it. The Sous, or the Line Chef.

    Like

  2. Yes, Kitty. I also find it hard to swallow when someone refers to themselves as a chef and to others as well, who also are not. But it’s become a term that seems to be changing in meaning, as do so many words in our lovely English tongue.

    Like

  3. My point exactly, misenplacememoir.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. misenplacememoir says:

    Good topic here. The term chef does get misconstrued a lot in America. I had the pleasure of working for a French chef in New Orleans who told me that all American chef’s are “shoemakers” and that American “chefs” make gravy, not sauce. But here was his point: Chef is Chief, with the culinary training, creativity and gumption to run a kitchen. Not a person with some of these traits but all of them. Not everyone who goes to culinary school can become a chef. Not every kitchen manager is a chef. The chef is leader, task master, creator, culinarian, organizer of the kitchen.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Kitty Morse says:

    Cynthia! You are on the mark, comme d’habitude. I am extremely uncomfortable at being called a “chef” when I am a cookbook author. I respect chefs for their training, which I have not gone through. I am a home cook who happens to write cookbooks!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s